Sunday, April 26, 2009

Geoff- Post 1 (pgs. 1-49)

I'd like to open up with this quote: "If this didn't work, then he knew he would die. He let himself go limp; he did not brace himself against the nausea. He didn't care any more if it came; he didn't care any more if he died." (39). So far, I'm really not liking this dude. I understand he was a part of the Bataan Death March, and he watched his cousin Rocky die, but I can't stand people that are sullen about life. I would hope that being a survivor would be evidence of Tayo's strength of character, that his love of life was carrying him through it all. But no; it seems Tayo survived the Death March because of dumb luck. Tayo's defining character trait is apathy; he's an emotionless shell of a man. I wish this kid would get excited about life; isn't surviving a brutal war something to be happy about? Yes, the author intends for the war to be life-changing, dramatic experience, but shouldn't that change the character for the better? Aren't people at their best only after hardship? (Remember Elie Wiesel, who became a writer and a humanitarian after the Holocaust?) There's my little rant; I hope this kid has a serious paradigm shift by the end of story, because this sob story is killing my enthusiasm for life (or just making me a little angry as I type). Whew.
On a different note, has anybody actually figured out the correct sequence of events? Because, for the longest time, I was thinking that the donkey ride to the bar was in the present. The randomly dispersed poems aren't really helping that.
Finally, I think the most telling part of the novel so far has been the bar scene, when everybody's plastered and Tayo's true colors show. This is the first real demonstration of cultural conflict in the novel, when Tayo starts railing on white people and how things were better during the war. If a theme of the novel is Laguna/Caucasian cultural conflict, I'd predict Tayo will find some sort of reconciliation between these elements so he can lead a normal life. Just a head's up, Laguna is not the native name of the Indians; they call themselves Kawaik. Laguna is of course, Spanish; it refers to a lake on Laguna land. They're a tribe of the Pueblo Indians, so, traditionally, they lived in those adobe houses.

9 comments:

  1. Ms. Champagne wasn't too specific in the blog instructions; I hope this is what she had in mind, although I'm aware I've got a lot of opinion here and not a lot of fact.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Geoff,
    Thanks for the post...no this is what I am looking for. I want conversations about the book. True feelings, but not just 'this book is boring, I am not liking this book'. Give your opinions and then...give me a bit more about what you are noticing and what you don't and do know.
    Thanks Geoff, be sure to remember to make comments on other postings.
    Ms Champagne

    ReplyDelete
  3. You an I are so harsh on Tayo! :)Do you like any of the characters yet? Do you really think that he will be able to lead a "normal life" later on?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Ha I agree with you guys on how Tayo is sort of cuckoo in the brain. He shouldn't be so hard on himself. Your blog has a lot of words! And details. It's awesome.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I dont completely agree with you guys, because war can drastically change someone's mental state. Such as when he believed he shot his Uncle Josiah, he may have been driven insane by the guilt of executing a helpless person.

    I think he's extremely hard on himself because he feels guilty for his Uncle disappearing and his Cousin's death. He had lost most of his loved ones and couldnt return to the happy times he had before the war.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Haha I laugh because your all like i hate people who have a sullen outlook on life, yet you have to sit next to miyana in math haha. I enjoy how you described what got him through the war wasnt love but pure dumb luck.

    ReplyDelete
  7. BLEH you just don't get Tayo. Also you're belief that you should be happy to survive war isn't always the truth. There are so many cases where people are so greatly traumatized by the death they see that they no long will to live. Would you be able be the same person if you saw your dad die in front of you in a war? But i must agree with you on the bar scene because i thought that was funny.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I totaly agree with Ryder because war does change a person...you cant not be changed after being away from your family for so long and then killing other people and that destroys there family too...Geoff i completly agree with you Tayo is really stange...how he is acting after he comes home from war. i know war changes you but i dont think that drasticlly...

    ReplyDelete
  9. I somewhat agree that Tayo will be able to live a normal life after he heals from his illness. i think that Tayo will never be the same person as he was before the war but he will be a "new" person and he will be able to live a somewhat normal life but those memories never go away and they will still affect him. do you think the book will get better the more we read... i think the book will be a lot easier to understand when we keep reading and learn the authors reading style.

    ReplyDelete